Washington Metro Objectivism Discussion (WMOD)

                    June 18 1997 Meeting

                  The Essence of Objectivism?

                      By David Saum

The June WMOD meeting will feature a talk by David Saum
on the Essence of Objectivism.  This subject was previously
considered at the November 1996 WMOD meeting, but the 
meeting was poorly announced and a rerun has been requested. 
 
Although the question of the essence of Objectivism has been 
dealt with by Rand, Peikoff and Kelley, further analysis of 
this crucial question is desirable since it may yield further 
insights into the significance of Rand's work.  This is not 
just an abstract question of academic interest since its answer 
determines who is an Objectivist and what constitutes new 
Objectivist thought. This talk will review the past analysis 
and attempt a critical analysis of it.  

The critical analysis will include several interrelated aspects 
of this problem:

a. Definition of Essence - The dictionary suggests that multiple 
meanings can be given to the term "essence" when it is applied to 
systems of ideas.  Is the essence of a system of ideas the major 
positions taken by this system, or is it the most fundamental 
positions that can be shown to give rise to the other ideas system? 

b. Essence of Other Objective Systems of Ideas - Modern science is 
probably the most successful objective system of ideas, and yet the 
question of the essence of science is rarely asked.  The history 
of science suggests that the scientific method is the essence of 
science, rather than any set of discoveries, no matter how fundamental.

c. Hierarchy and Essence - Objectivism holds that human knowledge 
is hierarchical, and this certainly applies to the system of 
Objectivism itself.  This suggests that only ideas from the most 
fundamental divisions of philosophy could be part of its essence.

d. Objectivity and Essence - What is the relation of the method 
of objectivity and the essence of Objectivism?  Since objectivity
is a commitment to focus on reality, isn’t there a conflict between
being objective and also being commited to a set of conclusions
about reality, unless they are very fundamental? 

This line of analysis suggests that the essence of Objectivism 
is the method of objectivity and not any set of Rand's conclusions 
in the major areas of philosophy.  In conclusion, some implications 
of this hypothesis are considered.

(Before the meeting you might read the chapter "Objectivism" in 
David Kelley's  "Truth and Toleration")


         When and Where is the WMOD Meeting?

Join us on Wednesday June 18.  You can either join us for
dinner at 7 pm and/or for the discussion at 8:15 pm at the
Fortune Chinese Restaurant at Baileys  Xroads, VA on Route 7
between 7 Corners and Columbia Pike (5900  Leesburg Pike
703/998-8888). You can take METRO to the West Falls  Church
stop and then take METRO buses 29A or 29B East on Route 7
toward Baileys Xroads. The Fortune is on this route. After
the meeting we can give you a ride back to a METRO station.
WMOD has arranged for a $15 fixed price dinner (including
tax and tip).  Or you can order from the menu.  Please RSVP
to WMOD (703) 820-7696 before noon Wednesday 6/18 so that we
can tell the restaurant how many tables to set up.

                           Summer Vacation 
 
No WMOD meetings have been planned for July and August, unless a
volunteer can be found to arrange them.  Please call WMOD to volunteer.


                      DC AREA CALENDAR


Institute for Objectivist Studies 1997 Summer Seminar

*7/5-13 at the University of Virginia in Charlottesville, VA.
Contact http://ios.org, ios@ios.org, or phone 914/471-6100.

IOS and Cato Institute

 *10/4: ATLAS & THE WORLD, 
40th Anniversary of Atlas Shrugged, at the Renaissance
Washington Hotel in Washington DC. 
Contact http://ios.org, ios@ios.org, or phone 914/471-6100.

  

               WMOD Contact Information

The WMOD newsletter is $10/yr,  email newsletter is free.

Contact: Dave Saum
WMOD
PO Box 8007
Falls Church, VA 22041
Email: DSaum at infiltec.com, Phone: 703/820-7696, FAX: 703/671-9350
Web: http://www.infiltec.com/wmod.htm

----------- "Sapere aude" (dare to know) -------------------